Skip to content

Appeals from Justice Court

A party who disagrees with a judgment from Justice of the Peace Court has the right to appeal. Unlike appeals in most court systems, an appeal from JP Court goes to district court (or parish court where one exists) for a trial de novo — a completely new trial where the case starts fresh. This document outlines the appellate procedure, applicable deadlines, and the distinctions between types of appeals.

Any party to a JP Court case may appeal the final judgment. This includes:

  • The plaintiff, if judgment was against them
  • The defendant, if judgment was against them
  • Intervenors and third-party defendants
  • Anyone else affected by the judgment

The appeal is not limited to questions of law — the appellate court will hear the entire case anew.

Appeals from Justice of the Peace Court result in a trial de novo in the district court. This means:

  • Fresh start: The case is tried again from the beginning
  • New evidence: Either party may present new witnesses and evidence not offered in JP Court
  • No record review: The district court does not review what happened in JP Court — it conducts its own trial
  • Different judge: A district court judge presides over the new trial
  • De novo ruling: The district court reaches its own conclusion

This differs from appeals in appellate courts, which typically review the record for legal errors. A trial de novo permits the presentation of the case anew.

The appeal must be filed within 15 days from:

  • The date of the judgment, if notice is not required, OR
  • The date notice of judgment was served, if notice was required, OR
  • The date a motion for new trial was denied (or notice of denial served)

Notice is required in:

  • All contested cases (both parties appeared)
  • Default judgments where service was domiciliary

When notice is required, the appeal delay does not begin until notice is served on the party.

If a party files a timely motion for new trial:

  • The appeal delay is interrupted
  • If the motion is denied, the appeal delay begins fresh from the date of denial (or notice of denial)
  • If the motion is granted, there is no judgment to appeal until after the new trial

If the appeal is not filed within the 15-day period:

  • The appeal will be dismissed as untimely
  • The JP Court judgment becomes final and executory
  • The losing party has no further right to appeal in that case

Louisiana recognizes two types of appeals: suspensive and devolutive. The type chosen affects whether the judgment can be executed while the appeal is pending.

A suspensive appeal suspends execution of the judgment. While the appeal is pending:

  • The judgment cannot be enforced
  • No writ of fieri facias can issue
  • No garnishment can proceed
  • The winning party must wait for resolution of the appeal

To file a suspensive appeal, the appellant must furnish security (post a bond) in an amount determined by the court. The security protects the appellee if the appeal is unsuccessful.

A devolutive appeal does not suspend execution. While the appeal is pending:

  • The judgment remains enforceable
  • The winning party may execute (seize property, garnish wages)
  • The losing party must satisfy the judgment even while appealing

No security is required for a devolutive appeal.

The amount of security required depends on the nature of the judgment:

Money Judgment:

  • Security must equal the amount of the judgment, plus
  • Accrued interest, plus
  • Anticipated interest during the appeal, plus
  • Court costs

Property Judgment:

  • Security equal to the value of the property, or
  • Alternative arrangements approved by the court

Acceptable security typically includes:

  • Surety bond — Issued by an insurance company
  • Cash deposit — Money deposited with the court
  • Property bond — Real property offered as security (less common in JP Court)

If the appellant wins on appeal:

  • The security is released
  • No payment is made from the bond

If the appellant loses on appeal:

  • The security is used to satisfy the judgment
  • Any remaining amount is returned to the appellant

The appeal is taken by filing a suit for trial de novo with the appellate court. This is a new lawsuit that references the original JP Court judgment.

The suit for trial de novo must be filed with the District Court (or Parish Court) within the 15-day deadline.

Notice Requirement: The appellant must provide a copy of the suit for trial de novo (or notice of the suit) to the Justice of the Peace Court that rendered the judgment.

For a suspensive appeal, the required security is typically posted with the Clerk of the District Court at the time of filing.

After the Justice of the Peace receives notice of the suit for trial de novo, the court transfers the record to the district court. The record typically includes:

  • The case file (docket entries)
  • All pleadings and documents
  • Evidence exhibits
  • The judgment
  • Proof of service and notice

Once the record is transferred, the district court will:

  • Docket the case
  • Set a trial date
  • Issue any necessary notices to the parties

Because the district court conducts a new trial, the parties are not limited to the evidence presented in the Justice of the Peace Court and may present new evidence and witnesses.

The district court trial follows normal civil procedure:

  • Opening statements
  • Plaintiff’s case-in-chief
  • Defendant’s case
  • Rebuttal
  • Closing arguments
  • Judgment

The district court may reach the same conclusion as the JP Court or a completely different one.

The district court will render its own judgment. This judgment may be:

  • Further appealed to the court of appeal (on questions of law only)
  • Executed if not appealed
  • Subject to the same post-judgment procedures as any district court judgment

Appeals from eviction judgments have special timing requirements.

An appeal does not suspend execution of an eviction judgment unless:

  1. The tenant filed an answer under oath, AND
  2. The answer pleaded an affirmative defense entitling the tenant to retain possession, AND
  3. The appeal was applied for within 24 hours of the judgment, AND
  4. The appeal bond was filed within 24 hours of the judgment

If these conditions are not met, the eviction may proceed even while the appeal is pending.

A devolutive appeal of an eviction judgment:

  • Does not prevent the landlord from obtaining a warrant of possession
  • May result in the tenant being removed before the appeal is heard
  • Allows the tenant to continue pursuing the appeal from a new location
ItemApproximate Cost
Filing the appealVaries by court
Transfer of recordUsually included
Security bond (suspensive)Judgment amount + interest + costs
District court filing fee$250-400 (varies by parish)

The costs of appeal are generally paid to the Clerk of the District Court.

Upon the rendering of judgment by the district court:

  • No Further Appeal: Under La. C.C.P. art. 4924(C), there is no right to appeal the district court’s judgment to a higher court. The district court’s decision is generally final.
  • Supervisory Writs: A party may apply for a supervisory writ to the Court of Appeal under La. C.C.P. art. 4924(D). This is a discretionary review, not a right.
  • Compliance: The judgment debtor must satisfy the judgment.
  • Execution: The prevailing party may execute the judgment.
  • Disposition of Security: If security was posted for a suspensive appeal and the appellant is cast in judgment, the security may be used to satisfy the judgment.

For information on judgments and enforcement, see Judgments. For the civil suit process, see Civil Suits. For garnishment procedures, see Garnishment.